“Of course the Americans Started the War,” or what I learned in NK (2)


North Korea 2012 358

I have 50 more analogous pics of me with KIS murals, statures, pictures, busts…

I went to NK this summer. In my first post, I noted how NK should probably be re-named Kim-land. Here are some more impressions:

1.a. Kim Jong Un was not so emphasized.

In passing, it is worth noting that KJU was not stressed that much. At the Arirang games, portraits of KIS and KJI were put up, but not KJU. Nor did we see any images of him at all. No portraits or murals. There were a few slogans using his names, but no imagery anywhere. We were told that is because of his modesty. He does not want to so glorified while he is still alive. I don’t buy that for a moment. Maybe it suggests he is still getting a hold of the state? Not quite sure what to make of it.

1.b. KIS and KJI equally deified?

Also noticeable was the equality between KIS and KJI, which surprised me. At the most famous image of KIS, the Mansudae grand monument, KJI has been placed right next to him, in similar size and on the same plane. The kremlinologist in me noted right away that KIS was not elevated above his son. This was also the case for their images on horseback at Mansudae Art Studio and when their images were presented to us at the Arirang Games (below). I kept trying to get a sense of which one was more important or greater, but couldn’t (and the guides ducked any questions that even hinted about this).

North Korea 2012 014

I kept thinking of how Stalin was placed in the Red Square mausoleum next to Lenin immediately after his death, but then, with destalinization, he was removed. He was buried behind the mausoleum, and even under the partial re-stalinization of Brezhnev, he was not put back. NK arguably reached its high point under KIS, who seems a little less dangerous than his son was. I wonder if a ranking will eventually emerge?

2. Get your terminology right!

My Korean is already an embarrassment, but all the unique NK vocabulary made it a pain and signaled that I had training in SK. Korea was ‘Choseon’ not “Han-guk,” which I knew beforehand but kept forgetting to say. This was politely ignored, but no one teaches you how to say ‘long live the great general comrade KJI’ in SK language schools. D’oh! And the Marxist-Juche vocabulary was a even harder – I don’t think I ever learned the word for ‘peasant,’ because there aren’t any in SK, but now I know. I would also forget to attach titles to KIS and KJI, like ‘comrade,’ ‘general,’ etc, which the guides were fastidious in using. I also kept almost using the South Korean parlance for North Korea (buk-han), which was a major mistake, but the words DPRK in Korean were a mouthful to learn. All in all, I kept putting my foot in my mouth.

North Korea 2012 189

3. Not as much propagandizing of the tourists as I expected.

I heard that visits to the Soviet Union involved a lot of ideology and agit-prop for the tourists, but this wasn’t the case for us. Maybe with the Cold War over, the travel service realizes we’d just fall asleep if they rolled that out. But I was surprised given NK’s reputation and the very obvious efforts to indoctrinate the N Koreans themselves. Occasionally we got guides who seemed like true believers, and the video at the captured USS Pueblo was a real hoot about decadent US imperialism turned back by the quiet heroism and might of the Korean people and so on. But as a rule, we weren’t bombarded by claims about western failure and socialism’s triumph and all that. When unification did come up, the idea of ‘one country two systems’ was the typical response. No one argued for a war (which was hardly surprising I guess, but still nice to hear). We were however sure to be told that the US began the war – not even Syngman Rhee and the South so much as the mi-guks.

4. God forbid you fail on-the-spot guidance.

We heard so much about KIS and KJI coming to this or that location to provide nuggets of wisdom like, ‘this restaurant should serve healthy food and the workers,’ that it got to be second-nature. Typically, when we reached a place or facility, a local guide would tell us what the institution was, and by the second or third sentence, tell us when KJI and KIS came to visit. In the metro museum, these dates were recorded in detail with a light display indicating when, where, and how often. Typically the guidance was banal – this ‘bridge should heroically serve the people’ – which apparently caused the builders to redouble their efforts and dramatically improved the quality of the bridge. Often the guidance was then inscribed into a gold-leaf plaque that was hung by the entrance so that all could read it immediately on entering. Or the plaques would be free-standing concrete edifices, presumably to indicate the enduring strength of the state. On My Paekdu, the locations where KIS/KJI stood were roped off with guards drifting about.

One moment stood out. We visited a collective farm that had heavy investment by China. Unlike so much else we had seen, it looked clean and functional. There was no cracking concrete, hulks of blown-out tractors, broken windows, etc. By NK standards, it was a marvel. Yet our local guide made sure to tell us in his second sentence that KJI had approved of it. And she said it in such a way that implied that if KJI hadn’t approved, they might have burned down the whole facility and plowed it under. This site was enormous and represented a large portion of NK agriculture in certain sectors. Yet all that hung on the capricious fancy of one man. The way our guide told us of his approval made it sound lucky that this otherwise excellent facility was approved and therefore operational. Good thing KJI wasn’t having a bad day that time or was otherwise upset – I guess that would have been a good enough reason to deprive the whole country of fruit. This was one of those moments that really reinforced the royalism I argued for in the first post.

North Korea 2012 205

Continued in Part 3.

13 thoughts on ““Of course the Americans Started the War,” or what I learned in NK (2)

  1. Great post(s) Robert.

    Regarding Kim Jong Un and the personality cult – my observation and interpretation was that KJU is seeking to leverage the existing personality cult around KIS and KJI, rather than expand it. I.e. given the breadth and penetration of the existing personality cult he only needs to remind the party, public and military that he is a Kim – and probably the only one they’ve got – in order to at least remain the nominal leader. Also, in a Confucian country I imagine it would be complicated to build a personality cult around a 29 year old, especially the youngest brother.

    Apparently KJU’s mother was born in Japan – an inconvenient fact which should relegate her to the ranks of the ‘Hostiles’. Perhaps another reason?

    I’m already 26 and not even close to being absolute ruler of a rogue state!

    • Thanks.

      That’s a pretty good explanation. But eventually, he’ll need to come into his own. Endless statues of his father and grandfather will eventually raise the question of where his statues are, no? KIS certainly had no problem putting up statues of himself. A personality cult focused on the past can’t last, no?

      • He may seek to build popularity in a more mainstream fashion. KJI only ever made one public statement (and it was about five words), whereas KJU has made several speeches already. KJU conducts many more photo ops with ordinary people (especially children) than KJI did. I think KJU is trying to channel the KIS cult – rather than recreate a new one. After all he already looks like KIS!

        And I think a personality cult can absolutely endure (and grow) over the long term. Look at Reagan and the way contemporary Republican candidates seek to position themselves as his heir. Look at the way constitutional fundamentalists promote the work of the founding fathers as perfect and divine, when it’s so not. Look at Ataturk. Look at Christ. All past or even ancient personality cults that endure, with many contemporaries seeking to channel the power and influence of their names.

        • But none of those guys, not even Attaturk, built an entire state around their every word and gesture. There’s no Attaturk bench museum, but I am pretty sure NK will build one to KIS and his footprints.

          • That’s true – the sheer scale and pervasiveness of the KIS/KJI perfonality cult seems unrivalled. But doesn’t that suggest the existing cult can endure long term, without a KJU cult bolted on?

            • I will actually post on this problem in 4 days in my last post on our trip. I still think there’s a time limit, solely because at some point the personality of the personality cult dies. At some point, the past is past, and simply becomes ritual and myth – like George Washington for Americans today.

  2. I was in the Soviet Union back in the late 80’s. No phony set-ups and propagandizing of tourists. They didn’t have anything worthwhile, though. Nice oranges from Cuba. Way too much chocolate and candy. Pepsi, not Coke. Food was atrocious. I had to wipe in a pubic restroom with squares of old photocopy paper. When I saw that the plumbing in my hotel room was joined with horsehair, I ceased to be afraid of the Soviets. I heard from some friends that once they saw the quality of manufacture of the Mig-29, they ceased to be afraid also.
    The one positive thing about the old Soviet Union: their airport security was a lot more polite and less intrusive than the TSA.

  3. Pingback: “Kim Jong Il was Born on Mt. Paekdu,” or what I learned in NK (3) | Robert Kelly — Asian Security Blog

  4. Pingback: “Kim Il Sung will always be with Us,” or what I learned in NK (4) | Robert Kelly — Asian Security Blog

  5. Pingback: Pyongyang isn’t ‘Laid-Back & Leafy’; or What Parag Khanna didn’t Learn in NK (5) | Robert Kelly — Asian Security Blog

  6. Pingback: Korean Gender Reader | The Grand Narrative

  7. Pingback: “Against Dogmatic Bourgeois Flunkeyism,” or what I learned in NK (1) | Robert Kelly — Asian Security Blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s