My Lowy Essay on that New Report on North Korean Human Rights: It won’t Change the North – but It will Pressure China


UN NK

This is a re-up of a short piece I wrote for the Lowy Institute’s blog on that recent North Korea human rights report from the UN. The more I think about it, the more I think its big impact will be to raise the moral pressure on China to either rein in North Korea or start cutting it off. NK is an embarrassment to China. My Chinese grad students get flustered and sheepish whenever I mention this. I think this moral embarrassment is the best way to push China on this. And once China finally cuts off NK, then we’ll see real change at last. I also thought this analysis piece from Foreign Policy was pretty good.

“This month the United Nations (UN) told us what we all already knew – that North Korea is the world’s worst human rights abuser. Specifically, the UN Commission of Inquiry on Human Rights in the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea (the formal name of North Korea) of the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights released a lengthy, well-documented report that North Korean repression, in the words of the Australian chair of the Commission, Michael Kirby, is “strikingly similar” to that of the Nazis. This is a landmark finding, not only for its willingness to call out North Korea explicitly, but for its origin in a multilateral body channeling global public opinion. I see four elements in the coming fall-out from this:

 

1. Because this comes from the UN, it carries the imprimatur of the international community in a way that reports from the western states and NGOs cannot.

This is probably the report’s greatest import. The findings themselves, however disturbing, are not really new. Even those who do not study Korea or Asia have known for a long time that North Korea is an orwellian hellhole. I had a (Korean) student who once wrote a paper claiming 1984 was the blueprint for North Korea. I recall reading once back in the 1990s, when the Taliban still governed Afghanistan, that human rights groups ranked North Korea even below them. (Here are the North Korea pages for both Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch.) More importantly, a robust North Korean defector/refugee literature has emerged in the last two decades. Barbara Demick’s book is probably the most famous, but the more North Koreans escape and tell their stories, the harder it has become to cover-up or deny the horrors.

Indeed, it is likely that this growing wave of defector literature helped push this investigation through from a major multilateral body with global credibility. Fairly or not, it is easier for reports from western or South Korean sources, whether governmental or non-profit, to be dismissed as ‘human rights imperialism’ or interventionist by those, such as China, who would rather not discuss North Korea’s gulags. But such claims from a UN body, complete with global membership, are far harder to dismiss. As such, I expect this report to be the new benchmark against which human rights critiques of the North are made.

2. The report’s origin with the UN will pressure China.

China is North Korea’s patron. Without the Chinese veto at the UN Security Council, North Korea would be even more isolated than it already is. China provides it with the fuel to keep factories running and the lights on. China also looks the other way on the massive smuggling taking place across the border. North Korea is technically under heavy sanction, but Chinese help – or at least, non-enforcement – reduces the bite of various embargoes. Certainly in my own experience, when I flew into Pyongyang from Beijing, there was no sanctions stop or check. Tourists loaded up on luxury goods like liquor and home appliances in duty-free and walked right onto the plane.

This is a pretty good deal for China. Chinese merchants and smugglers can charge cut-throat prices. The influx of various sanctioned goods keeps North Korea stumbling along and arguably helps forestall the country’s collapse. And all this interaction gives Chinese business privileged access to the North, particularly its prized natural resources. Chinese security experts openly refer to North Korea as a ‘buffer’ (I’ve heard this manipulative formulation at conferences repeatedly) between China and the democracies of South Korea, Japan and the United States.

But there are also a lot of ‘track II’ signals that China is uncomfortable with North Korea (again, I’m thinking of informal conversation on the conference circuit). The regime is so awful, that the alliance with China creates genuine reputation costs. The US ‘pivot to Asia’ is fuelled partially by China’s insistence on standing by North Korea, seemingly no matter what it does. This UN report is almost certain to be new ammunition in diplomatic efforts to pull China away from the North, and it guarantees another round of terrible press for China in both Asia and the West. This is good, as North Korea will probably not collapse until China finally pulls the plug. Normative pressure like this raises the ‘audience costs’ of Chinese support.

3. No sanctions relief will be forthcoming.

This report will also lock-in the extraordinarily tight sanctions regime around North Korea. As a report generated from within the UN, it will carry special weight in further UN deliberations on sanctions. The UN has a ‘Panel of Experts’ on the DPRK sanctions. They now have access to UN data without the politically controversial step of using information from member governments like South Korea with a vested interest in tougher sanctions. This will also raise pressure on China as the primary sanctions-buster.

4. Threatening prosecution at the International Criminal Court won’t help.

One unanticipated outcome of the report is the personal notification to North Korean leader Kim Jong Un that he may be held personally liable for the abuses and might be remanded, were it possible, to the ICC for criminal prosecution.

Human rights advocates often celebrate such threats as progress in human rights maintenance. They signal to potential future violators that there will be punishment and, hopefully, pre-emptively discourage violations. This ‘deterrence’ may work; the political science research on it is not clear as far as I know.

But there is a downside regarding despots already in power. To threaten them with prosecution almost certainly encourages to dig in deeper, to not give an inch. Bashar al-Assad is likely in such a situation. He has no exit, nowhere to go where he would be safe, so he fights all the harder to hang on. Kaddafi too signaled during the Libyan civil war that he was open to some kind of transition-for-escape deal. This never materialized, and he fought to the end. By contrast, Idi Amin was given refuge in Saudi Arabia.

In the North Korean case, it is often assumed the Kim family will run to Beijing when the regime starts to collapse. But if the Kims can find no refuge, because of efforts such as an ICC prosecution, or South Korean efforts to extradite them, then they are that much more likely to fight, possibly even launching an insurgency.

But all-in-all, this was a good day for human rights and tough one for China. That is progress.”

18 thoughts on “My Lowy Essay on that New Report on North Korean Human Rights: It won’t Change the North – but It will Pressure China

  1. The pressure will increase, for a while, but there is little indication that this sort of human rights brand image matters much to China. China itself is human rights abuser; China itself abuses N. Koreans through its refugee policy. I am sorry to say but states discount human rights too much for this report to be a fire bell in the night for China. South Africa withstood the worst pillorying of a state in modern times and it continued with apartheid until the security situation changed (Gorbachev’s ending support for revolutionary communism in Africa and the eschewing of nationalism by the ANC). Israel has continued a very harsh Palestinian policy and likely will continue until its perception of security improves. China is unlikely to let a human rights report or bad press affect its NK policy unless China concludes that N. Korea can be jettisoned without damaging China’s security (and the U.S. pivot may reinforce that concern not provide a rational for China distancing itself from NK as I think you suggest).

    Even with the U.S., the human rights issue regarding NK gets bollixed up with security. Security concerns use up all the oxygen devoted to NK. Witness the near invisibility of the 1990s N. Korean famine in US press and with policy-makers – almost all the talk then was on the NK nuclear program and there was an apparent tit-for-tat on US aid for NK security concessions.

    Finally, it is hard to believe that there will be much global hue and cry against NK over human rights behavior that the world has tolerated for decades, despite the UN imprimatur on this new report. And, this is especially so, since the one country which should be leading that moral crusade, is more concerned about human rights abuses which occurred 70 years ago in Japan. If South Koreans don’t talk that much about N. Korean HR abuses — if South Koreans are not willing to pay an economic or diplomatic price by standing up to China on its refugee policy/NK support — the rest of the world may ask why should it?

  2. If you step out from the range of a radio router whilst you’re over a call the call is going
    to be dropped. Some companies known for making excellent
    wireless signal boosting products are Netgear and Linksys.

    This will make certain that in case you are pickpocketed or your baggage gets lost or delayed or misplaced, you have still got some cash in hand.
    Just like camera and GPRS, wifi phones also have
    various versions, the newest the version may be the more enhanced will probably be the speed.
    Wifi extender att uverse As it stands now, the strain times with an average website take presctiption average ten times what they would be
    to get a Wi – Fi internet connection around the i –
    Phone.

  3. Pingback: My Lowy Debate on whether US should Retrench from South Korea, part 1: Yes | Robert Kelly — Asian Security Blog

  4. Creampie Massive Tits and Ass Mom MILF actually anal whore
    Attractive mother together with her doll Mom Needs
    Your Load – JOI Mom Says Goodmorning mother gropped
    in kitchen indian sex associates mother suck my cock 02 Milf
    Action Scorching Mommy-pal-son Threesome JW – Dirty Mother
    Take mother and shake Wife is lonely 1, half 2
    Good Morning Not Mother Amateur 65,584 3,198 Cum Swapping 1,523 33 Cum on Ass 7,271
    212 Cum on Back 2,538 101 Cum on Palms 2,208 83 Cum on Stomach four,849 221 Cum on Tits 19,085 965 Furry Pussy 36,582
    2,343 Choco Milf Milf Paranoia My Milf Clips Anal Momboy Tube Mommy Tube Obscene
    Granny Flix Mother + son + girl threesome All people on GRANNY exposed
    are 18 years previous or older, duh! Attractive busty MILF gets her snatch stretched by an enormous cock Sexy MILF exhibits
    her expertise when she will get assfucked arduous Boat
    sized juggs blonde BBW milf immediately from Prague!

  5. Candy bar fundraising could be very profitable and is successful when a tiny fundraiser is needed.

    This particular balance between length, width and height makes the body weight distribution uniform without affecting the sunlight bar or perhaps the roof on which these are mounted.
    Led light bar tube mounts The LED light bars will also be waterproof which enables you to use them for exterior lighting, a liberty you can’t
    usually take with other sorts of light sources.

    Modern office, trendy family area, quaint kitchen, or hip dorm room, you can find cool recycled furniture pieces to fit virtually
    any decor. When it truely does work in inert objects, it is called
    Apara Prakriti in spiritual terms.

  6. Pingback: Korean unification: a rising cost for Beijing | Global Geopolitics

  7. Retractable leashes are available and allow
    you to vary the freedom that you give your dog. This is the raising season which means it is the time of year when Christmas and holiday parties is going to be placed.
    However, cedar is short acting and needs to be reapplied often.

  8. Pingback: My Top 5 List for 2014: 5 Biggest Foreign Policy Events for the US in Asia | Robert Kelly — Asian Security Blog

  9. Pingback: My Top 5 List for 2104: 5 Biggest Foreign Policy Events in Korea | Robert Kelly — Asian Security Blog

  10. Pingback: Looking Back on What Predictions for East Asia 2014 I got Wrong…and a little Right | Robert Kelly — Asian Security Blog

  11. Pingback: Invading North Korea is a Really Bad Idea | Robert Kelly — Asian Security Blog

  12. młody jęczmień Dr. Mehemet Oz, host of the Dr. Oz present,
    advocates using a blender to combine inexperienced meals akin to celery, spinach, sprouts,
    parsley and cucumber with different well being-boosting meals corresponding to ginger and lemon.

  13. Pingback: Why ‘Women Cross the DMZ’ Was a Bad Idea: The Threat of Moral Equivalence | Robert Kelly — Asian Security Blog

  14. Pingback: Separating China from North Korea is Worth South Korea’s Silence on the South China Sea | Robert Kelly — Asian Security Blog

  15. sections that you experienced you’d like to have to take a lot more obligation with regard to? You need to write about your responses with the reviews down below.Excellent message. No matter if I select so that you can worried through the subsequent time or maybe regardless if I select calm for one more 60 minutes, transformations the nike free run neon understanding of exactly what happens in this 60 minute block as well as work day buying and selling domains interact with situations, at some point switching end results not to mention a long term future. While i tend to train on an automatic what from is situated this 60 minutes, subsequently that as well can deliver a distinct result.There’s really no valid reason to need to understand all kinds of things and turn linked to exactly what occurs your process. Choose the occasions in your own daytime when you will most definitely relax, or merely allow it to come to pass, while not ones own response.There is a alternative as to whether an individual answer or perhaps no matter if people answer to life’s situations. Whenever you are not really judgmental and are avalable even more using a location of ‘observation’ then you are more prone to ‘respond’ as opposed to ‘react’ nike free run ext together with in general, you certainly will believe additional peaceful.Personal Printing Meeting using Shannon Brenard

    People reside in a image modern society exactly where, correct or incorrect, particular personalisation is crucial for a victory. The fact is that ones impression, your reputation whilst your approach influence the way other individuals Nike free 5.0 opinioni choose your personal mind, truthfulness plus identity. Perception develops into inescapable fact. Those who prefer to master the work adventure realise that introducing a singular, rubbed skilled company is not just crucial for personal satisfaction though important thing effects on top of that.But it surely could tough require a mission examine how you would look as if many others, and even more challenging to switch this picture. These days, were showcasing a meeting utilizing an individual who may help you get cracking. Shannon Holmes can be described as major persona strategist and founder of Top rated Picture Worldwide a Contemporary Doing Classes meant for People plus the principal specialist of non-public type training.Pest Command Online sites

    There is fast hazard interior discussing your private home with a bit of silverfish or perhaps simple mice. However these kinds of beings are near a certain people stage, they are going to prove to be having typically the

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s