Off to China… 3) There was a Confucian Peace After All…


eindex01

About 8 months ago, I wrote that the notion of a ‘Confucian Peace’ was probably wrong. I thought that usually common cultures inspire competition for dominance. Like envies like. We save our greatest passion for inquisitions not crusades. We would rather punish errant insiders in the name of purity than hazy outsiders we can easily classify as ‘barbarians’ and forget about it. I figured Christians massacred each other for centuries over tedious doctrinal issues despite a New Testament ethic to turn the other cheek. So I figured the Confucian Asians (Japan, China, Korea, Vietnam) would be the same way.

But when I actually did the research it really turned out wrong for Confucians. While it is correct that Christians were hypocrites regarding ‘Christendom,’ Confucians generally were not among themselves. This does mean that Confucians states did not war. Like the Democratic Peace, a Confucian Peace posits only that Confucians don’t war on each other, not that they forgo war altogether. Below is the abstract and two of the graphs. If you want the whole paper, please email me. What is most important is the Confucian ‘peace score’ in the bottom table: one two-month war in 195 years of Confucian diplomatic history. That is quite striking compared to 92/151 war years for Christendom.

“International relations theory about East Asia has increasingly argued that East Asia before Western penetration enjoyed a protracted peace. As explanations, a Chinese military hegemony would fit IR theory fairly well, while a cultural peace based on shared Confucian norms would be a significant anomaly. A Confucian long peace challenges widely-held, albeit Eurocentric, IR presumptions including the perils of anarchy, the arms-racing and misperception of the security dilemma, and the regularity of power balancing. This paper therefore investigates, first, whether such peace did in fact exist, and, second, whether this might be attributed to Confucianism. A cultural peace theory requires a strong anti-war cultural norm and a shared sense of community. Skepticism is established by examining 3 comparative cultural spaces that nonetheless did not enjoy a culturally informed peace: the classical Greek city-state system, early modern Christendom, and the contemporary Arab state system. All were deeply riven and competitive. Nevertheless, empirical investigation of the last Chinese (Ching) dynasty before the Western arrival (1644-1839) demonstrates that it was remarkable peaceful toward its Confucian neighbors, while more ‘normally’ exploiting its power asymmetry against non-Confucian ones. Process-tracing specialized Chinese practices toward fellow Confucians suggests the low Confucian war finding emanates from cultural restraint.”

Model of a Politically-divided Cultural Community

Polities

                                           Japan

China

Korea

Vietnam

Cultural Base or Substratum

                                                                         Confucianism

 

Empirical Summary of Cultural Peace Cases

 

Classical Greece

Western Christendom

Modern Arab State System

Pre-Western Confucian-Ching System

Anti-War Ethic

No

Yes

No

Yes

Society of States

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Total War Years / Total System Years

73/141

92/151

8/55

(15/55)[1]

1/195

Percentage of ‘Cultural Peace’ Years

48.22%

39.07%

85.45%

(72.72%)

99.48%


[1] This second figure includes the Libyan 1980-87 invasion of Chad.

10 thoughts on “Off to China… 3) There was a Confucian Peace After All…

  1. Good graphs. Do you have any figures on Africa pre-colonialism. Chaka Zulu made wars of conquest all over Southern Africa before the Europeans arrived. His military machine was very sophisticated. What about the Arab conquests of the Maghreb?

    Also, Sub-Saharan Africa had a few large Kingdoms, that engaged in conquests as well.

  2. Hi Bob, A clarification question – what is exactly is the definition of the “Anti-war ethic/cultural norm”?

  3. Pingback: A Chill in Shangra-La | Left Flank

  4. Pingback: Global Security in 7 Minutes! (1. The World is Getting Safer) « Asian Security Blog

  5. Pingback: Hu, Obama, and the Chinese-Confucian Hankering for Status Recognition « Asian Security Blog

  6. Pingback: Some Recent Media | Robert Kelly — Asian Security Blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s